Friday, April 5, 2013

SWOT Analysis


Strengths:
The Cincinnati Zoo is one of the oldest zoo’s in the nation, the second oldest to be precise. A long history is a unique strength in that it provides the Zoo with experiences only gained through time. This strength has given the Zoo a solid reputation and an ability to adapt. The zoo’s greening initiative can arguably be linked to this ability to adapt and recognize what needs to be done.
Not only one of the nation’s first zoo’s the Cincinnati Zoo is also one of the first zoo’s to begin an intensive greening campaign. When, in 2006, the zoo recognized the wastefulness that led to $70,000 monthly water bills and high energy costs, it decided to do something. While a large investment was initially necessary, $1 million, the Cincinnati zoo’s green initiative has proven fruitful (Kubiak, 2011). Over $4.3million has been saved on utility bills alone. This investment in green technology has birthed the largest solar array in the nation, the use of animal byproducts, and rain gardens for water conservation, among other achievements (Cifuentes, 2013).
These cost saving initiatives have given the zoo an abundance of resources not only monetarily but in regards to recognition in sustainability, community initiatives, and enhanced fluidity. And so when the Zoo recognized a problem within its Avondale community- one of the city’s many food deserts- the zoo was able to make use of its relations and resources as well as its adaptability in its support for Gabriel Place campaign- a community garden market. Through the campaign local food is brought into Avondale (Cifuentes, 2013). By bringing local, healthy, and sustainably grown food into Avondale the Cincinnati Zoo is combating inequity. The people of Avondale were denied access to a green food source, something many of us take for granted with the number of Kroger’s or wholefoods across suburbs. 

Weaknesses: 
            The Cincinnati Zoo can bring sustainable food sources into the community but a number of barriers lie within the path. Should they provide the community with the financial resources to commit to community supported agriculture investment (CSA)? How do you convince a low income family buying sustainably grown agriculture, and maintaining a greener diet is in their best interest without paying for the enormous cost difference?
            This leads to a second weakness that must be considered in any sort of justice oriented campaign, and a question that comes up in discussion about “uplifting” any population. How can the zoo offer support but not fuel dependency? What happens if/when their financial resources are dry? Will Avondale fall back into an extreme desert?
            Another consideration that needs considered is the nature of the campaign. Is it vertical governance or horizontal organizing? In other words how inclusive can the Cincinnati Zoo remain in its efforts without slowing down its campaigns. The Zoo worked with the Avondale community council in its efforts to tear down buildings and build green space in place of these buildings but a number of potential weaknesses arise. What if the community council would have declined these initiatives? How can the Zoo continue to be inclusive without threatening its own sustainability? And so the governance of the Zoo seems to face potential weaknesses.
  
Opportunities:
The Cincinnati Zoo faces a number of opportunities with the current climate of green initiatives in favor of their efforts. When the Cincinnati Zoo built the Education Center, Cincinnati’s first LEED certified building, the Zoo was only in its planning stages. Since then nearby University of Cincinnati has gained recognition for its buildings with LEED certification as well as the city of Cincinnati in its sustainability efforts. The Zoo was one of the first green advocates in the region and remains at the forefront of sustainability efforts. This provides the Zoo a unique position in which it has the opportunity to continue to shape the public discourse regarding increasingly popular sustainability efforts.
The Zoo also has the opportunity to keep working with the Avondale community. As the city and the entire nation have become increasingly concerned with food deserts, the Cincinnati Zoo has continued to foster its position and relationship with the Avondale community. However more can be done. The Zoo can utilize its resources and build new relations with organizations. It is surprising that the Zoo has not worked with organizations such as “Closing the Health Gap” in merging health, education, and food insecurity (closingthehealthgap.org). This potential collaboration is a great opportunity for the Zoo.
Another opportunity rests in their ability to further their successes in waste reduction. The Zoo started making conservation a priority in 2006.  So far they have cut their water use to 1/3 of what they were once using, built solar panels that sometimes allows them to be off the grid, and has started recycling.  They are now looking to be zero landfill (<1% of waste going to landfill).  If this is what they have started with, who knows where they can go.
 
Threats:
Will the trend of sustainability come to an end? Once the recession comes to a full end will conserving funds and thus cutting waste, no longer be of concern? This is a threat to not the Zoo as much as the Zoo’s sustainability and greening campaign. The Zoo remains a business and thus must meet the needs of the consumers, if the public is no longer interested in green efforts or, even worse, if the public wants some sort of unsustainable design from the local Zoo, how will the Zoo react?
Along these lines, as the Zoo is a business and runs on the business model, will the green efforts ever be threatened by the business model of order? This falls in line with the environmental economics/ ecological economics debate- is the current business model itself unsustainable?
Finally, considering the Cincinnati Zoo’s green efforts are so closely linked to a number of organizations such as Green Bean Delivery, among others, what happens if these relationships fall apart? Whether because the other business models were unsustainable or some sort of dispute, the fact that the Zoo is tied to other groups in its imitative may pose some issues. What happens if the cooperative relationships themselves prove unsustainable?

Friday, March 15, 2013

Interview with Fia Cifuentes, Sustainability Coordinator at the Cincinnati Zoo

Q: When did the Zoo begin to have sustainability as a priority, and how did this start?

A: We are the 2nd oldest zoo, were we always green? Beginning about 2006 the Zoo started practicing sustainability. We opened the Education Center, the first LEED certified building in Cincinnati. In the planning stages in 2005-2006 there was a lot of discussion about building greener, and we needed to do it because it aligned with our mission. Mark Fisher with Turner Construction was on that project, and he is now the Facilities/Planning and Sustainability Director for the Zoo. He asked a lot of questions right from the start such as "Where are the recycle bins?.." The Green Team was restarted in 2009, made mostly of volunteers with knowledge in waste management, water.

Q: Could you compare early sustainability efforts with those of today?

A: Early on sustainability efforts were mainly line items on to-do lists for the zoo, and if no one asked about them they didn't get done. No one was "in charge" of sustainability. Now there are designated people in each department for sustainability. We won the Greenest Zoo in America award recently. Green wasn't even talked about for zoos until a few years ago. The AZA (American Zoo Association) and the AZFA (American Zoo Facilities Association) award green efforts. Green is a must now for construction, for architects, etc.

Q: What is the Zoo doing today to address waste, energy and water use?

A: Mainly though staff education and changes in procedures. We are teaching our own department methods to reduce waste. Then we can teach it to the rest of the zoo.  Mark Fisher looked at the Zoo's water bill. From 2006 to now, the Zoo reduced water use from 220 million gallons per year to 74 million gallons. This was the result of fixing pipe leaks, changing enclosure cleaning practices, and other reduction efforts. There was a small waterfall in one of the Tiger enclosures that was thought to be a natural spring, but it turned out to be a burst pipe that had been flowing for over 30 years! The savings from that leak alone were big enough to spend the savings on upgrading the filters in the manatee tanks. What pushed sustainability early on was Mark's drive, expertise, and the entire facilities staff. The Zoo has saved $4.3 million in utilities, through lots of electrical use reductions, getting the old out. Offices with multiple fridges running empty, dehumidifiers not dehumidifying anything, etc.. The Solar canopies in the parking lot are a big reduction in electric. We buy the electric produced and Melink Corp manages and maintains them.

Q: What is the Zoo doing with community involvement with regards to sustainability?

A: The neighborhood of Avondale and the Zoo butted heads a lot in the past. Now, we are working together to improve the community. An empty lot behind the Zoo employees' parking area was transformed into a park with a walking path, and there is discussion on how to improve usage of the park such as raised gardening beds. More greenspace for Avondale, there were some run-down properties that the Zoo purchased, tore down, and turned into greenspace. The buildings were deconstructed and 85% of the material was recycled. The neighborhood was thankful to have the eyesores gone. We work with the Avondale Community Council. Bill Wintton from the neighborhood is on the Zoo board. We help out with Gabriel's Place, a community garden and market. This would have been unheard of 20 years ago. Getting local food into Avondale, a food desert. We also do home weatherization help and energy efficiency upgrades working with PWC (People Working Cooperatively). We have the green home contest, run by the Uptown Consortium (Avondale, Coryville, Clifton, Mt. Auburn, and CUF). We also work with Green Umbrella, the regional sustainability alliance. Recently we have the Boyer Farm in Warren County, that was entrusted to the Zoo. It was being farmed conventionally but we are flipping it to more sustainable farming happening and a youth program that brings Avondale youth out to the farm to learn food and agriculture. Working with Green BEAN delivery to deliver local vegetables to people who sign up, like a CSA (Community Supported Agriculture) but it delivers.

Q: What does the future of Zoo sustainability look like?

A: We want to become a zero-landfill Zoo (less than 1% of waste goes to a lanfill). This will happen through waste reduction, composting, and recycling improvements. We did a trash survey and found that 80% of what we throw away could have been diverted from a landfill through recycling or composting. Staff education is another component. Color coded trash/recycling and composting bags. Going for green restaurant certification. SSA (Service Systems Associates) can change to compost able plates, napkins. We use a municipal composting facility that can handle food waste, unlike a backyard compost. Renaming Boyer Farm to ECOHIO, a joint of Eco and Ohio. Conducting a carbon footprint analysis for the farm, to add up all the Zoo carbon footprint. We are always looking for ways to reduce electric and water. We will have more storm water retention improvements, using permeable pavements and pavers, storage tanks, one half the Zoo is off the storm sewer pipes, and the other part is future work.








Friday, March 1, 2013

Tasks and Order of Execution

Works Cited
Cincinnati Zoo: Go Green. 2012. http://cincinnatizoo.org/conservation/go-green/ (accessed March 1, 2013).

Friday, February 22, 2013

Pictures of the Zoo's Projects for Sustainable Development


The zoo has installed a wind spire turbine that, with the help of the solar panels, runs 1/3 of the ticketing and membership buildings energy.



The largest publicly accessible solar panel array is at the Cincinnati Zoo, used as a roof for the parking lot. Also on the Zoo's website, they monitor how much the solar panel is generating in real time.

Link to the solar panel monitoring:


These rain gardens are strategically placed in areas to prevent erosion, pollution, storm water runoff, and flooding. Small plants that can absorb a high amount of water are found in these rain gardens, which helps in the same way a wetland purifies water.


Worm Composting

The zoo does a whole lot of composting. With all of the animals at the zoo, organic waste is a huge resource. Not only is the animal waste at some of the exhibits composted, but the lawn trimmings and food scraps are also composted. 1/3 of all of the organic waste at the zoo is composted.

Green Initiative - The Cincinnati Zoo. http://cincinnatizoo.org/conservation/go-green/green-initiative/. 

Monday, February 18, 2013

Key elements of the Effort

Thane Maynard is the executive director of the Cincinnati zoo. He approves all projects that go on at the zoo and takes every Sunday morning to help with different animals.
Mark Fisher is the Director of Facilities, Planning, and Sustainability. He manages and develops all projects that occur on the grounds. Not only does he create a beautiful and uniform landscape at the zoo, but he is driven to make it more sustainable everyday.

The zoo depends on devoted volunteers to help with local clean ups, taking care of the zoo itself, and any other work that is needed at the zoo. These people take time out of their day to give it too all of the animals and people that visit the zoo.

Sources:
Green Initiative - The Cincinnati Zoo. http://cincinnatizoo.org/conservation/go-green/ 
     green-initiative/. 

Pictures:
http://news.cincinnati.com/article/20090726/NEWS01/907270325/Cincinnati-Zoo-director-Thane-Maynard-embraces-animal-guy-


Friday, February 8, 2013

Zoo Director:  Thane Maynard
Approve all projects that go on at the zoo.
Chief Operating Officer:  Dave Jenike
Oversees how everything is operating at the zoo (includes,
but not limited to; animals, education, facilities, and research). 
Director of Facilities, Planning, and
Sustainability:  Mark Fisher
In charge of developing and managing all projects on the ground. 
Within these projects, he is pushed to bring sustainability to every part of the zoo.







Leader of Facilities                          Leader of Horticulture                             Leader of Park                                       Team                                                          Team                                                     Services
(manage the space                                (manage the plant designs                        (manage events
and equipment of the zoo)                  uses for sustainability)                        and entertainment)


Volunteers                         Staff








Friday, February 1, 2013

Their Mission

"The Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden has been dedicated to the conservation of plants and animals since 1875. Proclaimed the “Greenest Zoo in America” in 2010, the Zoo has continued to lead the way in sustainability and green initiatives by greening its daily operations and reducing its impact on the environment. Through green building, solid waste management, renewable energy, water conservation, storm water management, energy efficiency and community outreach, the Zoo has strengthened its sustainability program to have a positive impact on the planet."

Link to the Zoo's website:
http://cincinnatizoo.org/conservation/go-green/green-initiative/